Astute readers of my words (one can pretend) will remember I promised to relate my experiences with tubular tires, and it’s been a couple of weeks since I’ve mentioned them. Well that’s because I dumped them, and I have been waiting for some objective distance to say why. The inciting incident was a pair of flats within a week of each other. The first was a massive sidewall blowout on a group ride. The tire, a nicer Vittoria, had barely 300 miles on it. The sidewall just failed. The second was a flat when, if I followed the advice over at BKW, I shouldn’t have been riding them. It was pouring rain, and I was trying to sneak in some miles. Once I’d removed the shard of glass, I decided to try my Tufo sealant instead of switching tires to my spare: changing rear tires is more of a pain, I wanted to finish my ride on a tire I knew was glued securely, and I wanted to see how the sealant worked. After waiting the requisite ten minutes in the deluge, I had my answer. I had barely put a couple of bars of air in before a thin jet of latex shot out of the tire, covering my shoes and leaving me standing in a puddle of white six feet across. That, I think, is when I was done with tubulars.
Frustration aside, I came up with a few good reasons for not sporting the tubs. First, running tubs takes time. Aside from everything else, getting a flat means that for the remainder of the ride you’re on a semi-glued tire and you’re looking at a 45 minute glue job that evening. I decided I’d rather use that time doing something else. Riding for instance.
Second, riding tubs is expensive. My second flat was on a cheaper Vittoria tire. Honestly, all the good benefits of running tubs is erased if you use crappy tires. Cheap tubs ride harsher and are less resistant to flats. Good tubs cost $60 and up and $90 is where the really good ones are. While $60 for a good tire doesn’t seem obtuse to me, it does if every flat means I am performing surgery on it. The lack of demand for non-race tubulars also means that a good $45 clincher in tubular version runs $90 (the Continental GP4000, for instance). The doubled price is, I suppose, for the doubled amount of fun you get to have with them.
Finally, the failure of the sealant raises a serious question of what happens when you flat more than once on a long ride. I like to ride longer out and backs, often through less than comfy neighborhoods which always seem to have nice glass-carpeted areas. One flat and I am limping on my semi-glued spare tire. A second flat and I am depending on sealant to get me home. Or, standing on the side of the road waiting for someone to come pick me up. With clinchers, my first flat is repaired with the spare tube I carry. Subsequent flats can be fixed with the flat kit. If I cut patches in half, I could probably ride across the country with one patch kit and make it just fine as far as repairing flats goes. This is by far the biggest reason I dropped the tubs.
So yeah, no more tubs. I initially thought that I’d glue up my super light wheels with a set of very good tires and use them for a treat every once in awhile — i.e. when I’m not riding on streets, don’t have to be anywhere, am not riding with a group, and when it hasn’t rained recently. I think rides fitting that description occur about twice a year, so I am not holding out lots of hope for tub riding time.